Skip to main content

Which Clue Should You Buy? (Classic, Harry Potter, Junior and More)

Clue versions compared: the classic, Harry Potter, Clue Junior, Conspiracy, Liars Edition and the escape games. Which to buy for families, fans, kids and big groups.

Buy the classic Clue if you want one murder mystery for the whole family. Buy Harry Potter Clue if you have Harry Potter fans; it’s our favorite. Buy Clue Junior for kids under 8, and Clue Conspiracy for a party of up to ten.

Some links below are Amazon affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, King Panda Games earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

We own and have played classic Clue and Harry Potter Clue. We haven’t played the other versions below, so those come from Hasbro’s rulebooks, and we say so in each entry.

Version Players Age What’s different Our score
Clue (classic, 2023 edition) 2–6 8+ The original whodunit 4/5 Bamboo, 4/5 Pandas
Clue: Harry Potter 3–5 8+ Moving doors, Dark Mark events, house points 4/5 Bamboo, 5/5 Pandas
Clue Junior 2–6 4+ Two-sided board, two kids’ mysteries Not played
Clue Liars Edition 2–6 8+ An electronic Liar Button decides who’s lying Not played
Clue Conspiracy 4–10 14+ A secret-role party game Not played
Clue escape games 1–6 10+ Solve once, cooperative Not played

Player counts and ages come from Hasbro’s instruction pages for each game.

Clue versions compared by players, age and what makes each one different

Classic Clue Is the Safe First Box

The classic game is the one to buy if you’re only buying one. It seats 2 to 6, works for ages 8 and up, and needs no explaining. We give it 4/5 Bamboo and 4/5 Pandas in our Clue review.

The current US box is the 2023 edition. It renamed some suspects (Solicitor Peacock, Mayor Green and Chef White joined Miss Scarlett, Colonel Mustard and Professor Plum) and added 29 Clue cards that trigger events when you roll the magnifying glass, according to Hasbro’s 2023 rulebook. The deduction is the same as ever.

Check Clue price on Amazon →

Harry Potter Clue Is Our Favorite

“Is Harry Potter Clue better than regular Clue?” For us, yes. We like it more because of the fun twist with the Dark Marks and the doors that open and close.

The board has four house wheels in the corners. Rolling a house crest turns a wheel, which can open or close doors, change the secret passages, or reveal the Dark Mark. Dark Mark events cost house points unless you hold the right Help card, and you can be knocked out by running out.

Harry Potter Clue board set up mid-game with movers, dice and tokens
Our Harry Potter Clue board mid-game. Photo: Eric, King Panda Games

It’s a great game for kids, families and anyone who loves Harry Potter, and we rate it 4/5 Bamboo and 5/5 Pandas. The catch is the player count: it needs at least three, and stops at five.

Worth knowing: there are two different Harry Potter Clue games. The current Hasbro box (2020) is a reissue of the 2008 design with the moving wheels. “Clue: World of Harry Potter” from 2011 is a different game, with a Floo Network and a final accusation at The Burrow, according to its BoardGameGeek entry. Make sure the box has the house wheels if that’s the one you want.

Our How to Play Harry Potter Clue guide covers the rules in full.

Check Clue: Harry Potter price on Amazon →

Clue Junior Is for Kids Under 8

Clue Junior is a simpler version for ages 4 and up, with a two-sided board and two different mysteries on it, according to Hasbro’s Clue Junior page. It seats 2 to 6.

We haven’t played it. It’s the obvious pick for a family whose youngest players aren’t ready for the notepad yet.

Check Clue Junior price on Amazon →

Clue Liars Edition Adds a Lie Detector

The Liars Edition uses the standard board plus Truth and Lie cards and an electronic Liar Button, according to Hasbro’s Liars Edition page. It’s 2 to 6 players, ages 8 and up.

We haven’t played it. It’s aimed at families who want Clue with more table talk.

Clue Conspiracy Is a Party Game

Clue Conspiracy is a secret-role game for 4 to 10 players, ages 14 and up, according to Hasbro’s Clue Conspiracy page. Instead of solving a murder, the table is split into friends and secret conspirators.

We haven’t played it. It’s the only Clue that seats a big party, and it plays more like the games on our best social deduction games list than like classic Clue.

The Escape Games Are One-Time Puzzles

Hasbro also makes Clue escape-room games, such as Treachery at Tudor Mansion and The Midnight Hotel. They’re cooperative, for 1 to 6 players, ages 10 and up, and you solve each one once.

We haven’t played them. They’re a different kind of night from classic Clue, closer to an escape room in a box.

So Which Should You Buy?

  1. One murder mystery for the family: classic Clue.
  2. Harry Potter fans, 3 to 5 players: Harry Potter Clue.
  3. Kids aged 4 to 7: Clue Junior.
  4. A party of 6 to 10: Clue Conspiracy.
  5. Two players: classic Clue, which has an official two-player variant.

If you’d rather have a cooperative mystery with no dice at all, see our Mysterium review. For the classic game’s rules and tactics, read our Clue strategy guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which version of Clue is best?

For most families, the classic game. It seats 2 to 6 and works from age 8. For Harry Potter fans, the Harry Potter edition is our favorite; we rate it 5/5 Pandas.

What is different about the new Clue?

The 2023 US edition renamed some suspects, including Solicitor Peacock, Mayor Green and Chef White, and added 29 Clue cards that trigger events. The deduction rules are the same.

What age is Clue Junior for?

Ages 4 and up, for 2 to 6 players. It has a two-sided board with two different mysteries.

How many players is Harry Potter Clue?

Three to five. The classic game plays two to six.

Which Clue works for a big group?

Clue Conspiracy, a secret-role party game for 4 to 10 players aged 14 and up. Classic Clue stops at six.

Are there two Harry Potter Clue games?

Yes. The current Hasbro box is a reissue of the 2008 game with moving house wheels. Clue: World of Harry Potter (2011) is a different game with a Floo Network and an accusation at The Burrow.

King Panda Games

Get the Budget Board Games Guide

9 games under $30 we actually recommend, plus one email when we publish something worth your time.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

If you like Clue, try these

Six more games we’ve reviewed, picked by how they play first and who they’re for second. Bamboo is how easy it is to learn; Pandas is how much fun we had.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate DisclosureCopyright