Skip to main content

How to Play Harry Potter Clue (Dark Marks, Doors and House Points)

How to play Harry Potter Clue, and how it differs from the classic. Moving doors, Dark Mark cards, Help cards, house points and Dumbledore's office. We rate it 4/5 and 5/5.

Harry Potter Clue plays like classic Clue with a twist: you still work out who did it, with what and where, but a missing student has replaced the murder victim, the board’s doors open and close, and Dark Mark events can cost you house points. Run out of house points and you’re out. Make the right accusation from Dumbledore’s office and you win.

Need rules for another game? Browse official rulebooks for 49 games, straight from the publishers.

Some links below are Amazon affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, King Panda Games earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

We rate Harry Potter Clue 4/5 Bamboo and 5/5 Pandas. It’s a great game for kids, families and anyone who loves Harry Potter, and we like it more than classic Clue because of the fun twist with the Dark Marks and the doors that open and close. The photos on this page are from our own game.

This guide follows Hasbro’s rulebook for Clue: Wizarding World Harry Potter Edition, the 2020 Hasbro edition. It’s for 3 to 5 players, ages 8 and up.

Check Clue: Harry Potter price on Amazon →

What You’re Solving

A student has gone missing from Hogwarts. You play Harry, Ron, Hermione, Ginny, Luna or Neville, and you work out who attacked the missing student, with what spell or item, and where.

At setup, one of the six student cards is drawn at random and placed face up: that’s the missing student, and nobody plays them.

Suspects Spells and items Locations
Draco Malfoy Sleeping Draught Great Hall
Crabbe & Goyle Vanishing Cabinet Hospital Wing
Lucius Malfoy Portkey Room of Requirement
Dolores Umbridge Impedimenta Potions Classroom
Peter Pettigrew Petrificus Totalus Trophy Room
Bellatrix Lestrange Mandrake Divination Classroom
Owlery
Library
Defense Against Dark Arts

That’s 6 suspects, 6 items and 9 locations, the same shape as classic Clue. The lists above are copied from the detective notepad in our own box.

Harry Potter Clue detective notepad listing the suspects, items and locations
The detective notepad from our copy. Photo: Eric, King Panda Games

What’s in the Box

Beyond the usual Clue pieces, the Harry Potter edition adds four things:

  1. Four wheels, one in each corner of the board, one per Hogwarts house. Turning a wheel opens and closes doors, changes the secret passages, and can reveal the Dark Mark.
  2. 33 Dark Deck cards. Each one is an attack that can cost you house points.
  3. 33 Help cards. Allies, items and spells that protect you from Dark Deck attacks.
  4. 40 House Point tokens. Your house points work like health.

There’s also a third die, the Hogwarts die, which you roll alongside the two normal dice.

Harry Potter Clue Dark Deck, Hogwarts Mystery card backs and a Help card on the table
The Dark Deck, the Mystery cards and a Help card from our game. Photo: Eric, King Panda Games

Setup

  1. Turn all four wheels to START.
  2. Each player takes one Help card face up, plus house points by player count: 60 with 3 players, 70 with 4, 80 with 5.
  3. Draw one student card at random and set it face up: that student is missing. Everyone else picks a student.
  4. Put one suspect, one item and one location card in the envelope.
  5. Deal the rest so everyone has the same number of cards. Any extras go face down in Dumbledore’s office.
  6. The player whose birthday is next goes first.
Harry Potter Clue board set up mid-game with movers, dice and tokens
Our board mid-game. The four corner wheels open and close the doors. Photo: Eric, King Panda Games

What You Do on Your Turn

  1. Roll all three dice.
  2. Check the Hogwarts die. A Help symbol gives you a Help card. A house crest turns that house’s wheel one notch, which can open or close doors, reveal a secret passage, or show the Dark Mark. A Dark Mark on the die or a wheel means you draw a Dark Deck card.
  3. Move with the two normal dice, or take an open secret passage instead.
  4. Make a suggestion if you’re in a room, take a Help card, or end your turn.

Suggestions work exactly like classic Clue. Name a suspect and an item in the room you’re in, and the players to your left show you one matching card if they can.

You roll the Gryffindor crest and turn that wheel. The door you were heading for slams shut, and a Dark Mark appears. You draw a Dark Deck card: every character in the Trophy Room loses 5 house points unless they can show a matching Help card. That’s the twist in a nutshell. The board changes under your feet, and the danger can hit anyone.

Harry Potter Clue Dark Deck card reading Characters in the Trophy Room, lose 5 HP
A Dark Deck card from our game: everyone in the Trophy Room loses 5 house points. Photo: Eric, King Panda Games

Dark Marks and Help Cards

Every Dark Deck card says what’s happening, who it affects, how many house points it costs, and which Help card protects you. Show a matching Help card and you’re safe, and you keep the card. Otherwise you pay the house points.

Help cards are allies, items or spells. You get them from the Hogwarts die and by stopping on a star in the corridors. Keep each one unless it tells you to discard it.

Worth knowing: the Alohomora Help card lets you pass through closed doors. On a board where doors keep slamming shut, it’s one of the best cards to hold.

How You Win (and How Everyone Loses)

You can only make an accusation from Dumbledore’s office. When you get there, you can either look at the extra face-down cards or make your accusation. Get it right and you win. Get it wrong and you’re out, but you still show cards to other players.

Two other ways the game can end badly:
– Run out of house points and you’re out of the game. You lay your cards face up for everyone.
– If every player runs out, the rulebook says the Dark Forces have won, and everyone loses.

That shared danger is what makes it feel different from classic Clue. You’re racing each other, but you’re also all in trouble together.

Harry Potter Clue vs Classic Clue

Classic Clue Harry Potter Clue
Players 2–6 3–5
You find Suspect, weapon, room Suspect, spell or item, location
The board Fixed doors Wheels open and close doors
Extra danger None Dark Deck cards cost house points
Where you accuse Any room Only Dumbledore’s office
Can you be knocked out? Only by a wrong accusation Also by running out of house points
Our scores 4/5 Bamboo, 4/5 Pandas 4/5 Bamboo, 5/5 Pandas

The classic game still works for two players and up to six. Harry Potter Clue needs three. Our Clue review covers the classic, and which Clue to buy compares the other editions. The Board Game Family’s Harry Potter Clue review has another family’s take.

For Harry Potter fans, Harry Potter Clue is the version to buy.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many players can play Harry Potter Clue?

Three to five, according to Hasbro’s rulebook. Classic Clue plays two to six.

What does the Dark Mark do in Harry Potter Clue?

When a Dark Mark appears on the Hogwarts die or a wheel, you draw a Dark Deck card. It describes an attack and the house points you lose unless you can show the matching Help card.

How do the doors work in Harry Potter Clue?

Each corner of the board has a house wheel. Rolling that house’s crest turns the wheel, which can open or close doors, change secret passages, or reveal the Dark Mark.

Where do you make an accusation in Harry Potter Clue?

Only in Dumbledore’s office. From there you can either look at the extra face-down cards or make your accusation.

Can everyone lose in Harry Potter Clue?

Yes. If every player runs out of house points, the Dark Forces win and nobody does.

Is Harry Potter Clue good for kids?

Yes. It’s rated 8 and up, and we think it’s a great game for kids and families, especially Harry Potter fans. We rate it 4/5 Bamboo and 5/5 Pandas.

Is the 2020 Harry Potter Clue the same as the 2008 one?

The game design is the same. BoardGameGeek lists the 2020 Hasbro box under the same entry as the 2008 original, which had the same moving wheels, Dark Mark and house points.

King Panda Games

Get the Budget Board Games Guide

9 games under $30 we actually recommend, plus one email when we publish something worth your time.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

If you like Clue, try these

Six more games we’ve reviewed, picked by how they play first and who they’re for second. Bamboo is how easy it is to learn; Pandas is how much fun we had.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate DisclosureCopyright