Skip to main content

Does Cities and Knights Fix the Catan Robber? (Mostly, Yes)

Cities and Knights keeps the robber off the board early and lets your knights chase it away. Here's what it fixes, what it makes worse, and the exact rules.

Mostly, yes. Cities & Knights fixes the two things people hate most about the robber in base Catan: getting robbed blind in the opening turns, and having no way to get the robber off your hex except waiting for someone else’s 7. What it doesn’t do is make the robber gentle. Later in the game, a 7 can cost you more than it does in the base game.

Some links below are Amazon affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, King Panda Games earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Every rule on this page comes from the 2025 Cities & Knights rulebook published by Catan’s publisher. If you want the base-game robber rules first (who you can steal from, what a 7 does, where to place it), our Catan robber guide covers all of it. This page covers only what the Cities & Knights expansion (check Cities & Knights on Amazon) changes.

What People Actually Hate About the Robber

The robber’s problem is helplessness, not the theft itself. In base Catan the robber is live from the first 7, and the only ways to move it are another 7 or a Knight development card you may never draw. If the robber lands on your only ore hex on turn four, you just wait.

The complaints come back to three moments:

  1. The early 7. Someone with two settlements and four cards loses one of them before they’ve built anything.
  2. The parked robber. It sits on your 6 or 8 for several rounds because nobody else has a reason to move it.
  3. The pile-on. The table agrees you’re winning, and every 7 lands on you.

Cities & Knights answers the first two in the rules themselves. The third is table politics, and no expansion fixes table politics.

Base Catan Cities & Knights
When it starts working From the first 7 After the first barbarian attack, when it moves to the desert
A 7 before that Not applicable: the robber is live from the start Discards only (more than 7 cards, return half). No move, no steal
Ways to move it Roll a 7 or play a Knight card Roll a 7, chase it with an active knight, or play a Taxation card
What it steals 1 random card from one player on the new hex The same, but Taxation steals 1 card from every player with a building there
Hand limit on a 7 More than 7 cards: discard half The same, but commodities count, and each city wall adds 2 (up to 3 walls)
The robber in base Catan vs. Cities & Knights, from each game’s rulebook.

The Robber Doesn’t Exist Until the Barbarians Land

At setup the robber isn’t on the island at all. The rulebook has you place it beside the last space of the barbarian track. The first time the barbarians attack, you move it to the desert, and from then on it works as usual.

Cities and Knights robber timeline: at setup the robber waits beside the barbarian track, before the first attack a 7 only forces discards, after the first attack it moves to the desert

What most new tables assume: a 7 before the first attack does nothing, so you can hoard cards freely.

What the rules actually say: the 7 still triggers the discard. Anyone holding more than 7 cards, counting resources and commodities together, returns half of them, rounded down. Only the robber move and the steal are switched off.

The barbarian ship moves when the event die shows a ship, and three of the die’s six faces do. So the first attack arrives after a stretch of turns that varies with the dice, not on a fixed round. That’s enough time to place your opening settlements, start a road, and maybe build a city before anyone can rob you. The early-game robbery that makes new players quit base Catan can’t happen, which makes your opening placement safer than it is in the base game.

Your Knights Can Chase It Away

This is the real fix. An active knight on an intersection next to the robber’s hex can take the Chase Away the Robber action. You move the robber to a new hex, steal one random card from a player with a building there, and your knight lies down as inactive.

The base game has no equivalent. A robber on your 8 is now a problem you can solve on your own turn, with a piece you placed on purpose, instead of hoping for a card.

Say the robber is sitting on your 8 hills, the hex that feeds every road and wall you plan to build. You have a basic knight two intersections away along your road. Moving it next to the hills lays it down, so this turn you move it and pay 1 grain to stand it back up. Next turn it’s active at the start of your turn, and you can chase the robber off and steal a card on the way out.

How to chase the robber in Cities and Knights: turn 1 move a knight next to the robber's hex and pay 1 grain to activate it, turn 2 chase the robber and steal a card

That two-turn delay is deliberate. The rules let you recruit a knight and activate it in one turn, but never activate a knight and then use it the same turn. Recruiting costs 1 wool and 1 ore, and activating costs 1 grain.

The rule: a knight that will chase the robber has to be standing at the start of your turn. Keep one activated knight beside your best number hex before the robber shows up, not after.

What Cities and Knights Makes Worse

Every knight you use on the robber is a knight that isn’t defending against the barbarians. When the ship lands, the barbarians’ strength equals the number of cities on the board, and the defenders’ strength is the total of every active knight. If the barbarians win, the player who contributed the least has a city knocked back to a settlement. So chasing the robber just before an attack can cost you a city.

After every attack, all knights lie down as inactive, whatever the result. Your robber insurance has to be bought again with grain each cycle.

Then there’s Taxation. The deck has two Taxation progress cards. Each one moves the robber and steals one random card from every player with a building on the new hex, not just one. It can only be played after the first barbarian attack. In base Catan the Knight card steals from one player; a Taxation card can rob the whole table at once.

Worth knowing: city walls are the only rule that raises your hand limit. Each wall adds 2 to the number of cards you can hold on a 7, up to 3 walls. That matters more here than in the base game, because commodities count toward your hand. A wall does nothing to stop the robber landing on your hex.

Is It Worth Buying for the Robber Alone?

Not for the robber alone, but if your group’s main complaint about Catan is the robber, it’s the strongest argument for this expansion. Cities & Knights also removes the development deck and the Largest Army tile, adds three city improvement tracks and progress cards, and raises the win target to 13 points. The publisher lists 90–120 minutes on the official Cities & Knights page, against 60–90 for base Catan.

If your table wants a bigger, slower game with real defensive decisions, the robber fix comes with it. If you just want a new map, our Cities and Knights vs Seafarers breakdown explains why Seafarers is usually the better first expansion. All four Catan expansions, from Seafarers to Explorers & Pirates, are ranked in our Catan expansions ranking, and BoardGameGeek’s Cities & Knights page collects the rules questions people ask most.

Check Cities and Knights price on Amazon →

Cities & Knights requires the base game. Still deciding on that? Start with our full Catan review, and our Catan versions ranking explains which base box to own. If your group has cooled on Catan altogether, our list of games like Catan is the better place to look.

Frequently Asked Questions

When does the robber come into play in Cities and Knights?

After the first barbarian attack. Until then the robber waits beside the barbarian track, nobody steals on a 7, and the Taxation card can’t be played either. The first attack moves the robber to the desert, and it works normally from then on.

Does the robber block commodities in Cities and Knights?

Yes. A hex with the robber on it produces neither resources nor commodities when its number is rolled. A robber on a mountain hex next to your city costs you the coin as well as the ore.

Can the robber steal progress cards?

No. A robber steal draws from resource and commodity cards only, and the Taxation card says outright that progress cards may not be stolen. Your progress cards are safe from every robber move.

Can the Invention card get a number out from under the robber?

Yes, as long as it isn’t a 2, 6, 8 or 12. Invention swaps two number discs, and the robber stays on its hex instead of moving with the disc, so you can move a blocked 5 or 9 onto an open hex.

Does a knight that chased the robber still defend against the barbarians?

Not until you reactivate it. Chasing the robber lays the knight down, and only active knights count toward the defenders’ strength. Pay 1 grain to stand it back up before the ship lands.

Does Seafarers change the robber in Cities and Knights?

It adds the pirate. Knights on sea intersections can chase the pirate away the same way land knights chase the robber, but the Taxation card can only move the robber, never the pirate.

Before your next Cities & Knights game, put one knight beside your best number and activate it before the barbarians land.

King Panda Games

Get the Budget Board Games Guide

9 games under $30 we actually recommend, plus one email when we publish something worth your time.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

If you like Catan, try these

Six more games we’ve reviewed, picked by how they play first and who they’re for second. Bamboo is how easy it is to learn; Pandas is how much fun we had.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate DisclosureCopyright