Skip to main content

Which Board Game Expansion Should I Buy? Free Compare Tool

Compare Catan, Dixit, Dominion, Everdell, Spirit Island and Wingspan expansions: what each adds, what it fixes, and which ones the rulebooks say not to mix.

Every expansion box promises more of the game you like. What the box doesn’t tell you is what it actually changes, whether it fixes anything, and whether it works with the expansion you already own.

So we built a comparison. Pick a game and two or three of its expansions to see them side by side. Tick what’s already on your shelf, or switch to gift mode for what’s on theirs, and it names the next one to buy. The facts come from each publisher’s store pages and rulebooks. The labels, buy order and one-line takes are our own picks, drawn from our expansion rankings. They’re research-based opinions, not play reports.

Some links below are Amazon affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, King Panda Games earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Compare expansions side by side

Pick a game, then choose two or three expansions. Tick what you already own and we’ll tell you what to buy next.

Compare (pick 2 or 3)

Already on your shelf?

Catan expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
SeafarersBuy this firstThe safest Catan buy: everything new sits on top of rules you already know, so there's almost nothing to relearn.30 land and sea hexes, 6 frame pieces, 60 ships (15 per color), a pirate, 5 Wonders of Catan tiles and 9 scenarios.Adds islands to reach by ship, so the map keeps opening up after the main island fills.3–4 (5–6 with extensions)$56Buy on Amazon →
Cities & KnightsWorth itThe box that turns Catan into a longer, deeper game. Great for veterans, too much for a table still learning the base rules.90 cards, 36 player pieces, 4 city improvement boards, 3 metropolis pieces, an event die, and a barbarian ship and track.Gives cities commodities to spend on city improvements, and a barbarian threat that rewards building knights.3–4 (5–6 with extensions)$60Buy on Amazon →
Traders & BarbariansWorth itLess one expansion than a box of small variants. Good if your group likes switching things up, but it changes Catan less than the top two.5 scenarios (Fishermen of Catan, The Rivers of Catan, Merchant Train, Barbarian Attack, Traders & Barbarians) plus variants including event cards and a two-player game.Adds small, separate twists you can pick per game instead of one big new rules system.2–4 (5–6 with extensions)$65Buy on Amazon →
Explorers & PiratesMost groups can skipAmbitious enough to feel like a different game, but the extra complexity doesn't always pay off. Buy the other three first.Ships that move freely and carry settlers, crews, fish or spices, new frame pieces and hexes, and 3 kinds of missions (pirate lairs, fish and spices).Turns the game toward sailing out to find and settle islands that are not on the map at the start.3–4 (5–6 with extensions)$65Skip it (here’s why)

CATAN says previous and current editions can be used together. Mixed boxes show different card backs, 6th Edition roads are slightly larger, and 6th Edition 5–6 player sets use purple instead of brown.

Every expansion has its own 5–6 player extension, sold separately. Playing an expansion with 5 or 6 takes four boxes: the base game, the expansion, the base 5–6 player extension and that expansion's 5–6 player extension.

Seafarers and Cities & Knights combine using official rules. Explorers & Pirates cannot be combined with Seafarers because their ship rules differ.

The Traders & Barbarians box linked here is the older edition. The 6th Edition box exists but was unavailable on Amazon when checked.

Dixit expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
QuestBuy this firstThe only pack by the base game's artist, so it blends in and nobody can guess cards by art style. That's why it goes first.84 large cards drawn by Marie Cardouat, the illustrator of the base game.Doubles a base deck that starts repeating, in the same art style you already know.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
JourneyWorth itDarker, busier pictures that reward story-style clues. The pack that makes an old deck feel new, not just bigger.84 large cards by Xavier Collette.Brings a different illustrator's style into a deck that has started to feel familiar.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
OriginsDepends on your groupFantasy pictures give everyone shared reference points, so clues land more often. Skip it if your table finds fantasy twee.84 large cards by Clément Lefèvre, themed on fantasy worlds.Adds fantasy imagery that many players find easy to give clues for.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
MemoriesDepends on your groupBuilt around childhood memories, so it invites clues about feelings rather than objects. The best pack for grandparents and kids at one table.84 large cards by Carine Hinder and Jérôme Pélissier, themed on childhood memories.Adds pictures built around childhood and nostalgia.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
RevelationsDepends on your groupEvery crowded card offers several clue angles. Patient groups love that; impatient ones slow down.84 large cards by Marina Coudray, in a detailed, illuminated style.Adds busy, detailed cards with many small things to give a clue about.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
AnniversaryOnly if you want everythingA sampler of every artist. More fun once you own three or four packs, and the one to grab first while it's still in stock.84 large cards for Dixit's 10th birthday, about ten each from the illustrators of the earlier packs.Gives you a sample of every Dixit artist in one box.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
DaydreamsDepends on your groupThe hardest pack. Sparse, abstract cards push veterans to clever clues and leave newer players with nothing to hold onto.84 large cards by Franck Dion, themed on waking dreams.Adds stranger, more surreal pictures for groups who find the deck too easy.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
MirrorsDepends on your groupEveryday scenes with something slightly off. Best for players who would rather clue a bus stop than a griffin.84 large cards by Sébastien Telleschi, showing dreamlike takes on daily life.Adds everyday scenes for players who find fantasy pictures hard to clue.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →
HarmoniesOnly if you want everythingGood cards that are the hardest to clue, so they get passed over for louder ones. Buy it last, and don't mix it up with the separate Harmonies game.84 large cards by Paul Echegoyen, built around contrast.Adds subtle, finely drawn cards to a large collection.Same as your base game$32.99Buy on Amazon →

All nine packs are 84 cards and nothing else. You need a Dixit base game for the board, scoring track, rabbit pawns and voting pieces.

Dixit Odyssey and Dixit Disney Edition are complete standalone games, not expansions. Libellud says the expansion cards work with all three base games.

In the US, Journey was also sold as a standalone game called Dixit: Journey with its own board. Make sure the box says expansion if you only want the cards.

The 2021 Dixit base game seats 3 to 8 and uses voting dials instead of voting tiles. The cards and rules did not change, so every pack still mixes in.

Dominion expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
Prosperity (2nd Edition)Buy this firstOur first pick: Platinum and Colony let games build to one huge turn, with nothing new to teach.300 cards: 25 new Kingdom cards, 12 each of two new Basic cards (Platinum and Colony) and Victory Point tokens.Platinum and Colony add a step past Gold and Province, so games can build to bigger turns.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
Seaside (2nd Edition)Buy this firstThe best first buy if you want something genuinely new: Duration cards make you plan across two turns.300 cards: 27 new Kingdom cards built around Duration cards, plus 12 player mats for Island and Native Village.Duration cards stay in play and do something on your next turn, so one turn sets up the next.2–4$39.95Buy on Amazon →
Intrigue (2nd Edition)Buy this firstBase Dominion with sharper edges and the nastiest cheap attacks. Pick it if you just want more of the game you know.300 cards: 26 new Kingdom cards, including cards that give you a choice of effects and Victory cards with a second type (Harem, Mill, Nobles).More of what the base set does, with more decisions on each card.2–4$39.95Buy on Amazon →
Hinterlands (2nd Edition)Worth itBuy it for the buy phase: its "when you gain this" cards make every shopping trip a real decision.300 cards: 26 Kingdom cards whose central theme is doing something when you buy or gain them. The 2nd edition swaps in 9 new cards.Many cards trigger when bought or gained, which adds choices to the buy phase.2–4$39.95Buy on Amazon →
MenagerieWorth itThe most inventive modern set, with card quality well above its quiet reputation.400 cards: 30 new Kingdom cards, a pile of Horse cards, 6 Exile mats, Ways that give Actions another option, and Events.Ways give every Action card in the game a second option, and Exile lets you set cards aside and get them back.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
Dark AgesWorth itA whole expansion about trashing. If Chapel is your favorite base card, this is your set.500 cards: 35 new Kingdom cards, Ruins you give to other players, Shelters that replace starting Estates, and cards you can only get through other cards.Built around the trash and upgrading: cards that do something when trashed and cards that improve themselves.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
Cornucopia & Guilds (2nd Edition)Worth itGentle, clever additions that mix with anything. The easiest late add to a collection.300 cards: 26 new Kingdom cards, 6 Reward cards, 35 coin tokens and 6 Coffers mats.Cornucopia rewards having many different cards. Guilds lets you save coins for later and pay extra for some cards to get a bonus.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
AdventuresDepends on your groupGood, but it adds a whole new system to track. Save it for when your table knows Dominion cold.400 cards: 30 new Kingdom cards (including Duration and Reserve cards), 20 Events, 6 mats and 60 tokens.Events give you something to buy besides cards, and tokens modify card piles.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
EmpiresDepends on your groupBuying now and paying later changes how you plan every turn. Rewarding, but best once your group knows the game well.300 cards and 96 metal tokens: 24 Kingdom piles (some split piles with two different cards), 21 Landmarks and 13 Events.Debt lets you buy cards now and pay later, and Landmarks add new ways to score.2–4$49.95Buy on Amazon →
NocturneDepends on your groupGood, but the Night phase adds a step to every turn. A box for experienced tables, not a second purchase.500 cards: 33 new Kingdom cards, Night cards played after the Buy phase, Heirlooms that replace starting Coppers, and Boons and Hexes.Adds a Night phase after buying, so turns have one more step.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
RenaissanceDepends on your groupProjects that last all game are a great idea, but it's one more system to learn. Wait until the basics are second nature.300 cards: 25 new Kingdom cards, 35 coin tokens, 6 Coffers/Villagers mats and 12 cubes for Projects.Tokens let you save coins and actions for later, Projects grant lasting abilities, and Artifacts are fought over.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
PlunderDepends on your groupOne of the strongest newer sets, and Loot cards are the highlight. Better once you've met Duration cards in an earlier box.500 cards: 40 new Kingdom cards with many Treasures and Durations, Loot cards, Traits that modify piles, and Events.Loot cards are Treasures you can only gain through other cards.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
AlliesDepends on your groupStrong, but it lands better after Durations and Events from other sets. A later buy, not an early one.400 cards: 31 new Kingdom card piles, Ally cards that grant Favors, split piles you can rotate, 6 Favor mats and 35 coin tokens.Liaison cards earn Favors that you spend on the game's Ally.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
Rising SunDepends on your groupA strong recent set that builds on ideas from earlier boxes. Get a few others first.300 cards: 25 new Kingdom card piles, Shadow cards, Prophecies, 13 Sun tokens and 40 Debt tokens.Shadow cards can be played from your deck, and Prophecies change the rules partway through the game.2–4$44.95Buy on Amazon →
AlchemyOnly if you want everythingThe set most players rate weakest. Bought early, it can sour you on expansions; buy it only to finish the collection.150 cards: 12 new Kingdom cards and 16 Potions, a new Basic Treasure needed to buy most of its cards.Adds a second currency, the Potion.2–4$29.95Buy on Amazon →

Every expansion here needs the Basic cards (Treasure, Victory and Curse cards) from base Dominion or the Base Cards set.

Intrigue's first edition could be played on its own. The second edition dropped the Basic cards, so it needs the base game.

Seaside, Prosperity and Hinterlands also come as $14.95 Update Packs with only the 9 new cards. Those need a first-edition copy of that expansion.

Rio Grande lists a 17th expansion, Arcana, as coming in Q4 2026. It isn't in this comparison yet.

Everdell expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
PearlbrookBuy this firstThe expansion Everdell was waiting for: a second economy on top of the base game, without rewriting rules you already know.A river board, a Frog Ambassador for each player, pearls, Adornment cards and four 3-D Wonders, plus 20 new critters and constructions.Gives you a big goal (Wonders) to build toward beyond your 15-card city.1–4$60Buy from Tycoon →
NewleafWorth itThe best "more Everdell": deeper rather than wider, for players who love the base game exactly as it is.A Station board with Train Car rewards, 32 Visitor cards, 59 critters and constructions, Golden occupied tokens, and optional Ticket and Reservation modules.Adds more face-up cards to choose from, which offsets the bigger deck.1–4$60Buy from Tycoon →
MistwoodDepends on your groupThe pick if you mostly play alone or as a pair. Nightweave is built to act like a real opponent, not just a score to beat.Nightweave, an automated rival for solo or two-player games, plus the Corrin Evertail, Legends II and Through Every Season packs.Gives solo and two-player games a tougher rival than Rugwort. You win only if you outscore Nightweave.Nightweave: 1–2 · mini packs: any count$60Buy from Tycoon →
SpirecrestDepends on your groupThe most divisive box. Weather adds variety some players love and others resent, because one bad card can wreck a careful plan.A Mountain board, 12 Weather cards, 33 Discovery cards, map tiles for an end-of-game Expedition, and 5 rideable Big Critters.Each season plays differently, because a Weather card changes the rules for that season.1–4$60Buy from Tycoon →
BellfaireMost groups can skipClose to essential if you often play with five or six; skip it otherwise, since Everdell isn't at its best with that many players.Rules and parts for 5–6 players, 15 Player Power cards, a shared Market, Garland Awards, a Flower Festival event, new Forest locations and player boards.Lets 5 or 6 people play.1–6$45Skip it (here’s why)
Complete CollectionOnly if you want everythingOnly makes sense if you're starting from zero and know you want everything. Otherwise, Pearlbrook alone is the better buy.The base game, all five expansions, Collector's Edition content, storage trays and one combined rulebook.One box instead of six, with storage built in.1–6$350Buy from Tycoon →

The Newleaf rulebook recommends not adding Pearlbrook or Spirecrest when you play with the full Newleaf expansion or its Station board.

The Spirecrest rulebook recommends playing it without other expansion material. (Tycoon's store page says you can combine it, so the two publisher sources disagree.)

Mistwood's Nightweave works with most other expansions, but not with the base game's Rugwort solo opponent.

Mistwood already includes the Corrin Evertail, Legends II and Through Every Season mini packs, so don't buy those separately.

Spirit Island expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
Jagged EarthBuy this firstTen new spirits is the fastest way to make a game you know feel new again. The easy first buy.10 spirits, 2 Adversaries (Habsburg Monarchy and Russia), 3 Scenarios, 2 island boards, Badlands tokens, 6 Aspect cards, 30 Event cards and 57 Major and Minor Power cards.More than doubles the base game's 8 spirits and lets you seat five or six players.1–6$69.95Buy on Amazon →
Branch & ClawWorth itSmaller, but its Events change the feel of every round. Buy it first if your group knows the Invader deck by heart.2 spirits, the France Adversary, 4 Scenarios, an Event deck of 25 cards, Beast, Wilds, Disease and Strife tokens, and 52 Major and Minor Power cards.Events and tokens make the Invader Phase less predictable from round to round.1–4$34.95Buy on Amazon →
Nature IncarnateDepends on your groupSubstantial and for experienced players only, and it needs Jagged Earth too. A third box, not a first.8 spirits, 20 Aspects on 24 cards, the Habsburg Mining Expedition Adversary, 2 Scenarios, 7 Incarna tokens, and new Power, Event, Fear and Blight cards.Gives experienced players new spirits and a large set of Aspects that change spirits they already own.1–6 (with Jagged Earth)$59.95Buy on Amazon →
Feather & FlameMost groups can skipThe two promo packs in one small box. Nice if you want more spirits, but most collections can skip it.4 spirits, the Scotland Adversary, 2 Scenarios, 5 Aspect cards, 5 Fear cards and 18 Unique Power cards.Adds more spirits and an Adversary with no new system to learn.1–4$34.95Skip it (here’s why)
Horizons of Spirit IslandMost groups can skipA starter set, not an expansion. Buy it as a cheaper way in or as a gift, not as an add-on to the base game.A complete starter game: 5 beginner-friendly spirits, its own 2- and 3-player island board, Invader and Fear decks, and a quick start guide.Gives new players a cheaper, simpler way into Spirit Island.1–3$34.95Skip it (here’s why)

Nature Incarnate needs both the base game and Jagged Earth. Every other expansion needs only the base game.

Jagged Earth includes the Branch & Claw tokens and rules, so you can play all of it without owning Branch & Claw.

Horizons of Spirit Island is a separate starter game for 1 to 3 players, not an expansion. Its five spirits do work with the rest of the line.

Only Jagged Earth adds island boards for five and six players. Nature Incarnate also plays up to six, because it uses those boards.

Wingspan expansions at a glance

ExpansionOur labelOur takeWhat it addsWhat it fixesPlayersPriceBuy
OceaniaBuy this firstFixes the base game's most annoying moment, holding food that fits no bird you want, and its birds are good enough to leave in for good.95 birds, nectar (a new food), 5 new player mats, 5 new food dice, 5 bonus cards, 4 goal tiles and yellow eggs.Nectar works as any food, so you're less often stuck holding the wrong food for the bird you want.1–5$35 list, $32 at StonemaierBuy on Amazon →
EuropeanWorth itThe quietest box, and that's the point: more birds, nothing new to teach.81 birds (some with round-end powers or more player interaction), 5 bonus cards, 5 goal tiles, purple eggs, food tokens and a card tray.More bird variety with no new rules to teach.1–5$30 list, $25 at StonemaierBuy on Amazon →
AsiaDepends on your groupDivisive but good for the right group: essential if you mostly play as two, optional otherwise.90 birds, 14 bonus cards, a Duet mode with a shared map for two players, and a Flock mode for six or seven.Gives two players a shared map to compete over, and is the only box that seats six or seven.1–2 on its own (Duet) · 6–7 with Flock mode$45 list, $39 at StonemaierBuy on Amazon →
AmericasDepends on your groupNot a bad box, just the most rules to teach for the least reason to rush it. Buy it last.111 birds, 40 hummingbird cards (a new, smaller card type), a garden board, hummingbird tracks and player mat overlays, 8 bonus cards and 5 goal tiles.Adds hummingbirds, a second kind of card with its own garden and end-of-game scoring track.1–5$30 at StonemaierBuy on Amazon →

Wingspan Asia plays on its own for one or two players. Its 6–7 player Flock mode needs the base game's player pieces.

Wingspan Pocket, Wyrmspan and Finspan are separate games, not expansions.

Stonemaier's own store sells below list price: Oceania $32 (list $35), European $25 (list $30), Asia $39 (list $45).

Which games are in the comparison?

The tool covers these games right now. Each links to our full ranking:

We only add a game after we've checked every expansion against the publisher's own pages and rulebooks, so the list grows a game at a time.

How we check the facts

Each row in the table comes from a source you can click. What's in the box, the player counts and the list price come from the publisher's store page. Whether two expansions should be mixed comes from the rulebooks. When those two disagree, as they do for Everdell's Spirecrest, we show you both. Prices are the publisher's list price, plus the publisher's own store price when it sells for less. The labels, from "Buy this first" to "Most groups can skip", are our editorial calls, and each game's expansion ranking explains why. These are the pages we checked:

Catan

Dixit

Dominion

Everdell

Spirit Island

Wingspan

If you're still deciding on a base game, our Catan review and our Spirit Island review are good places to start. Not sure what to play tonight at all? Our Game Night Picker ranks games for your table. Every game in the tool also has a full expansion ranking with our reasons, linked in the list above. We rank expansions for Ticket to Ride too, as well as for Root and Mysterium.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do 6th Edition Catan expansions work with an older Catan base game?

Yes. CATAN says previous and current editions can be used together. Expect different card backs, slightly larger 6th Edition roads, and purple instead of brown in 5–6 player sets. Card sleeves or replacement cards from CATAN fix the card backs.

What do I need to play a Catan expansion with 5 or 6 players?

Four boxes: the base game, the expansion, the base 5–6 player extension and that expansion's own 5–6 player extension. Each expansion has a separate one.

Do Dixit expansions work with Dixit Odyssey and Dixit Disney Edition?

Yes. Libellud says the expansion cards are compatible with all three base games: Dixit, Dixit Odyssey and Dixit Disney Edition. Every pack uses the same rules.

Is Dixit Journey an expansion or a full game?

Both exist. Dixit 3: Journey is an 84-card expansion that needs a base game. In the US, Dixit: Journey was also sold as a standalone game with its own board. The cards are the same.

Can you play Dominion Intrigue without the base game?

Only the first edition. The second edition, sold since 2016, has no Treasure, Victory or Curse cards, so you need base Dominion or the Base Cards set. The Dominion Big Box (2nd Edition) includes both base Dominion and Intrigue.

What is a Dominion Update Pack?

An Update Pack holds only the new cards from a second edition, for people who already own the first edition. It can't be played without that first-edition box. If you don't own the expansion yet, buy the full second edition box.

What is the best Everdell expansion for 2 players?

If the two of you play against each other, Pearlbrook: the river and Wonders work at any count. If you'd rather team up against the game, or one of you also plays solo, Mistwood adds Nightweave, an automated rival you both have to outscore. Skip Bellfaire at two; it exists to support five and six players.

What is the best Everdell expansion for solo play?

Mistwood. It replaces the base game's Rugwort with Nightweave, a tougher automated rival, and it includes the Corrin Evertail, Legends II and Through Every Season packs.

Is Spirecrest or Pearlbrook better?

Pearlbrook if your group likes to plan, Spirecrest if they like surprises. Spirecrest's Weather cards change the rules every season, and its rulebook recommends playing it without other expansions.

Can Nature Incarnate be my first Spirit Island expansion?

No. The publisher says Nature Incarnate needs both the base game and Jagged Earth. Jagged Earth, Branch & Claw and Feather & Flame each need only the base game.

Do I need Branch & Claw to play Jagged Earth?

No. Jagged Earth includes the Branch & Claw tokens and a copy of the Branch & Claw rules, so all of its content is playable without Branch & Claw. Branch & Claw still adds its own Event deck, two spirits, France and four Scenarios.

What is the best Wingspan expansion for 2 players?

Asia. Its Duet mode adds a shared map that two players compete over, and it plays on its own for one or two without the base game. For three to five players, Oceania is the better first buy.

Is Wingspan Pocket an expansion?

No. Wingspan Pocket, Wyrmspan and Finspan are separate games. None of them adds birds to the original Wingspan.

King Panda Games

Get the Budget Board Games Guide

9 games under $30 we actually recommend, plus one email when we publish something worth your time.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate DisclosureCopyright