Skip to main content

Cribbage Strategy From Every Possible Hand, Scored

Cribbage strategy backed by math. We scored all 12,994,800 hands and dealt 1,000,000 more to find what to throw to the crib, when to keep fives and what a good hand is.

Most cribbage advice says “keep your fives” and “throw kings to your opponent’s crib.” We checked both against the math. We scored every possible cribbage hand, all 12,994,800 combinations of four cards and a starter, then dealt 1,000,000 six-card hands and tried all 15 ways to discard each one. The old advice holds up, and the numbers show exactly how much it’s worth.

Some links below are Amazon affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate, King Panda Games earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

This guide assumes you know the rules. If not, start with how to play cribbage, and if you’re deciding whether the game is for you, read our guide Is Cribbage Worth Learning?.

How We Did the Math

Our scoring engine follows the American Cribbage Congress rules: fifteens, pairs, runs, flushes and nobs. First we scored every four-card hand with every possible starter card, exactly. Then we dealt 1,000,000 random six-card hands and, for each one, scored all 15 possible keeps against all 46 possible starters.

To value the crib, we averaged every pair of cards an opponent could throw in, so it reflects a typical crib rather than a perfect one. We didn’t model pegging, which matters too; these numbers cover the hand and the crib.

1. Know What a Good Hand Looks Like

The average cribbage hand, counted with its starter, is worth 4.77 points. Half of all hands score 4 or less, and 7.8% score nothing at all.

Hand score Share of all hands
0 points 7.8%
2 points 21.7%
4 points 22.0%
6 points 13.9%
8 points 8.8%
10 or more 7.4%
20 or more 0.12%

Distribution of every possible cribbage hand score, from our count of all 12,994,800 four-card hands and starters: average 4.77, 7.8% score zero, and 19, 25, 26 and 27 are impossible

Four scores are impossible: 19, 25, 26 and 27. That’s why players call a zero-point hand a “nineteen.” The perfect 29 hand turned up only 4 times in all 12,994,800 combinations, or 1 in 3,248,700: three fives and the jack of the starter’s suit, with the fourth five cut as the starter.

2. Choosing Well Nearly Doubles Your Hand

When you pick the best four cards from your six, the average hand jumps from 4.77 points to 8.29. That gap of about 3.5 points per hand is the single biggest skill edge in cribbage.

The tempting move: keep the four cards that score the most right now.

What actually works: keep the four cards with the best average across every possible starter. The starter is one of 46 unknown cards, and the best keeps are the ones that most of those cards improve.

3. Your Crib Changes the Right Throw

The best discard depends on whose crib it is. In our million deals, the best throw as dealer was different from the best throw as pone 58% of the time.

  • When it’s your crib, keep the hand and crib in mind together. Throwing for both, instead of for your hand alone, was worth 0.34 points per deal as dealer.
  • When it’s your opponent’s crib, throw cards that won’t help them. Doing that, instead of ignoring the crib, saved 0.20 points per deal as pone.

Those sound small, but cribbage games are often decided by a few points, and they add up every deal.

You’re dealt 2-3-5-5-6-10 (mixed suits). As dealer, keep 5-5-6-10 and throw 2-3 into your own crib: about 9.5 points in your hand on average, plus a crib worth about 6.8. As pone, keep 2-3-5-5 and throw 6-10 instead. Your hand drops to about 8.6, but the dealer’s crib drops to about 3.8, and you come out ahead.

4. Never Give Away a Five

Fives are the most valuable card in cribbage, because every ten-card (10, J, Q and K) makes 15 with them. In our simulation, the pone was dealt at least one five in 40% of deals, but the best discard sent a five to the dealer’s crib only 1.3% of the time.

Two cards thrown into a crib Average crib value
5-5 9.0
5-J (same suit) 7.3
5-6 7.1
5-10 7.0
2-3 6.8
7-8 6.8
J-Q 5.0
Q-K 4.0
A-K 3.7
10-K 3.4

Our cribbage crib-value table: a pair of fives thrown into a crib averages 9.0 points, 7-8 averages 6.8, and 10-K just 3.4

5. Throw Kings to Your Opponent

Kings are the safest cards to give away, because a king can only be part of a run from one side (J-Q-K). Our simulation’s most common best throw as pone was 10-K, and the six most common pone throws all contained a king.

As dealer, the most common best throws were 7-8 and 2-3, cards that work together and with any five. It’s the same logic in reverse: help your own crib, starve your opponent’s.

The rule: as pone, throw wide (cards far apart, like 10-K or A-K); as dealer, throw close (cards that touch, like 7-8, or that add to 5, like 2-3).

Check cribbage board price on Amazon →

Playing a lot? A good board makes a real difference over hundreds of games. Our best cribbage boards guide covers seven, from travel sets to heirloom gifts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best cribbage strategy?

Choose your four cards for their average value across every possible starter, and factor in whose crib it is. In our simulation of 1,000,000 deals, picking the best keep raised the average hand from 4.77 to 8.29 points.

What is the average cribbage hand?

4.77 points, counting the starter. That’s the exact average over all 12,994,800 combinations of four cards and a starter. Half of all hands score 4 or less.

What are the odds of a 29 hand in cribbage?

Of all 12,994,800 combinations of four cards and a starter, only 4 score 29, or 1 in 3,248,700. You need three fives and the jack of the starter’s suit, with the fourth five cut as the starter.

Should you throw a 5 into the crib?

Only into your own crib. A pair of fives averages about 9 points in a crib, the most of any two cards. In our simulation the pone’s best discard included a five only 1.3% of the time.

What cards should you throw into your opponent’s crib?

Cards that are far apart and don’t add to 15, especially kings. 10-K averaged just 3.4 points in a crib, the lowest of any pair, and it was the pone’s most common best throw in our simulation.

Why is 19 impossible in cribbage?

No combination of four cards and a starter adds up to exactly 19 points under the scoring rules. The same is true of 25, 26 and 27, which is why players call a zero-point hand a “nineteen.”

Put together: keep the four cards with the best average, protect your fives, and throw wide when it’s your opponent’s crib. To see the best throw for any six cards, try our free cribbage hand calculator.

King Panda Games

Get the Budget Board Games Guide

9 games under $30 we actually recommend, plus one email when we publish something worth your time.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate DisclosureCopyright